Skip to content

correction to commit "Updates to fix soft_masking discripancy - ENSC…

Marek Szuba requested to merge github/fork/duartemolha/release/97 into release/97

Created by: duartemolha



  • Filling out the template is required. Any pull request that does not include enough information to be reviewed in a timely manner may be closed at the maintainers' discretion;
  • Review the contributing guidelines for this repository; remember in particular:
    • do not modify code without testing for regression
    • provide simple unit tests to test the changes
    • if you change the schema you must patch the test databases as well, see Updating the schema
    • the PR must not fail unit testing


The commit here:

was trying to correct some discrepancies in the softmasking on non-coding sequences However, completely non-coding exons have a undefined $ex->coding_region_start resulting in warning messages

Use of uninitialized value in numeric gt (>) at ...EnsEMBL/

After setting all the sequence to lower case at line 837 exon_seq = lc(exon_seq) the if statements if ($ex->coding_region_start($self) > $ex->start()) { and if ($ex->coding_region_end($self) < $ex->end()) { should never be done since both coding_region_start and/or coding_region_end will be undefined if if (!defined ($ex->coding_region_start($self))) is true

Use case

This bug will output warning messages for completely UTR exons where the optional softmask has been set

for example for gene DDR2 , transcript id ENST00000367921

even though the output softmasking in correct before and after my code change, in the updated code we do not get warning messages such as Use of uninitialized value in numeric gt (>) at .../ensembl/modules/Bio/EnsEMBL/ line 837.


The change I made makes it so that when checking a complete UTR exon (when soft_masking is requested) is all lowercase, and then the comparisons with coding start and coding end with the start and end of the exon are ignored,

Those comparisons are only done IF $ex->coding_region_start is defined if (!defined ($ex->coding_region_start($self))) { exon_seq = lc(exon_seq); }else{ if ($ex->coding_region_start($self) > $ex->start()) { ... }

      if ($ex->coding_region_end($self) < $ex->end()) {

} $seq_string .= $exon_seq;

Possible Drawbacks

none that I can see


No. I have not created tests for this. The current tests available test to see if the boundaries between lowerCase and upperCase match. For exons that are completely UTR, both the previous code and the new code would make the entire exon sequence lowercase. The only difference is that after my change there is no invalid if comparisons with undefined values and therefore no warning messages. In order to test for this we would need The code builds fine on the current test suit

Merge request reports